CEO Pulse: Early AI Adopters See Big Returns
While each week in September brought a different headline about whether AI would end us all, members across Vistage are focused on a different question: how can I scale AI in my business?
In a live poll at recent Vistage Executive Summits in Orange County, San Francisco and Minneapolis, leaders in the room shared their biggest concern about scaling AI for their business.
- What was their top concern? Data quality and security.
Results from the live poll included the following additional concerns, in rank order:
- Team skills and readiness
- Trust in the outputs/accuracy
- Selecting the right tools
- Cost/unclear ROI
Our surveys show that small and midsize businesses are using AI, and many are uncertain about how to best deploy it.
Editor’s Note: This is part of a new ongoing series examining top-of-mind concerns and challenges for CEOs of small and midsize businesses and how Vistage members are addressing them. Vistage CEO members can continue the conversation in our Chief Executive Network (login required).
Data Quality is Foundational to AI Success
While a major concern is how secure company data is when shared with large language models (LLMs), another challenge is whether you can trust the resulting data.
During a Q&A following Kiingo AI CEO Ross Hartmann’s keynote, a member in Minneapolis asked, “When you have something created, and you are going to post externally, how confident can you be that it doesn’t contain proprietary information from somebody else?”
Ross assuaged their fears, sharing that LLMs don’t memorize data; rather, they look for patterns. Even if someone (a competitor) had training turned on and granted an LLM permission to train, the model would need to see the data several times before it would appear in someone else’s output. Ross’s view: chances are slim to none that you will echo back proprietary information from someone else.
(Whew. I know many of you are thinking that as well.)
On the topic of keeping data secure, Ross shared an impactful analogy during his presentation. He asked us to think about a brand-new employee and how we train and enable them by providing access to company systems, files, process documentation, and any historical data or knowledge that would help them get up to speed.
Then, he asked how successful that employee would be in the organization if, out of fear, we did not give them access to any of these tools. He encouraged us to see AI as labor, giving it access to the tools and data it needs to succeed. That shift in perspective can help leaders understand that the more data and context they provide — to both human and digital employees — the better the outcome will be.
Team Readiness: Change Management with Big Payoff
One of the most interesting responses in the CEO Confidence Index framed the challenge of AI in the context of employee buy-in.
John Kookoostedes, CEO of IAG Insurance Services in Orange County, is a regular respondent to our surveys. He shared how IAG is focused on using AI, like many of us are, to ” improve accuracy and efficiencies in repetitive or low-value tasks.”
The challenge, he says, is not the work. Rather, it’s “keeping employees from sabotaging the initiative — and having leadership feel the confidence to take the chance.”
While the response was related to AI, this is a classic change management challenge that exists in the face of any disruption.
San Diego member Joe Lenart, another early AI adopter, is a registered patent attorney and founding shareholder of Kennedy Lenart Spraggins. In a video he posted on LinkedIn, Joe says that “[AI] changed my business, fundamentally shifted my business, [and] got us ahead of the competitors.”
His journey was inspired when, after just 2 months in Vistage, Ross came to his group. Joe gained an understanding of where his industry was going and developed a plan that allowed them to get there faster than anyone else.
“I got on an AI warpath,” Joe admits.
It took some time to infuse this enthusiasm with members at his firm, as they were — in his words — “kicking and screaming.”
Joe held firm — no pun intended — reinforcing that their AI initiatives would give them a greater advantage, which was key to his change management. And in terms of clear ROI? The results spoke for themselves: attorney productivity surged, ranging from a 70% increase to a 2x increase.
Your biggest AI risk isn’t moving too slowly; it’s moving without guardrails. Download Provide and Protect: Gen AI Governance for CEOs and build a framework that protects your business.
Selecting the Right Tools
In Nashville, Tennessee, International Scholarship and Tuition Services (ISTS) has gone all in on AI. CEO Becky Sharpe shared a 4-year vision with her leadership team on how AI could strengthen ISTS and enhance the client experience. That vision guided the development of an “AI Roadmap” aligned with their strategic plan.
The journey began with Discovery in 2024, followed by Adoption in 2025, helping employees learn and apply AI in their work. Now in its third year, ISTS is focused on building its AI governance strategy and establishing company tools, training, and reporting to support individual roles and ensure consistent use.
In year 4, ISTS will scale up these capabilities to improve efficiency and support business growth.
ISTS COO Munyette Moore shared details about their investments, which include various AI tools to support enterprise productivity. After monthly team surveys about the tools used for different tasks, ISTS committed to supporting the efforts of different roles with investments including:
- Google Gemini for automated document processing
- Microsoft Copilot for productivity, analysis, communication, and workflow support
- Perplexity for research and market intelligence
- Gamma for AI-assisted presentations
- Workwolf for talent-related processes.
Their strategy aligns with what experts say: use the right tool for the job. You wouldn’t drive a Maserati to stock up at Costco or use a pocketknife to cut down a tree.
Simply put, different LLM models pair well with different tasks. ISTS recognizes the unique capabilities of different tools and has given its team access to them with great results.
Additionally, their ROI tracking is impressive. Improving accuracy, service levels, client experience, and scalability were table stakes for their AI investments. Munyette, who focuses on execution, proudly reported that their labor savings total 3,992 hours, a statistic they recently shared at a company meeting.
ISTS has also realized 5-figure expense reductions and a 25% increase in overall productivity. Munyette shared that one investment alone — Gemini-enabled document processing — has already helped ISTS avoid replacing two full-time positions left vacant from attrition.
Both of these members are not just using AI to achieve efficiencies; they have thought through how they can gain a competitive advantage and have recognized that team readiness and change management are critical components. Even more importantly, they have specific measures of results.
Questions To Ask Yourself
- How can we measure ROI from our AI usage?
- How effectively am I managing change among team members who are apprehensive as adoption accelerates?
- Are we investing in the right tools for the job we are doing?
Vistage members: Add your thoughts to the conversation, share your best practices, and learn what others are doing to drive AI adoption.
Later this month, I’ll be in St. Louis, Charlotte, and San Diego. As the data from the Q3 Vistage CEO Confidence Index and our analysis of top challenges is fresh in my mind, I will be listening for specific approaches and examples from members.